Fresh Expressions and The Sacraments

The May edition of e-expressions has an interesting piece from Bishop Graham Cray about the place of communion within a Fresh Expression of Church.  He highlights the defining characteristics of a church as:

One of the ways by which we can recognize whether something is church, is whether ‘the Word and the Sacraments’ are present. Scripture is studied, so that disciples can understand what Jesus wants them to know and do, and act accordingly. Communion is celebrated to rehearse what Jesus has accomplished and set our eyes, minds and hearts on his coming kingdom. If a fresh expression is really church it will develop to a stage where Holy Communion (under whatever name a tradition uses) is part of its regular pattern of worship and discipleship. This is for the most basic of reasons. Jesus told us to share bread and wine in this way in remembrance of him. It’s that simple!

This has been an area that has caused concern for any form of innovative worship within a church that is catholic in nature like the Church of England.  It seems that whenever the Anglican church tries to engage with new groups of people one of the first things that is removed from an act of corporate worship is the sacrament.  This can be seen historically in the Family Service movement throughout the last century or more recently in the alt worship scene.  It is an area that I looked into as part of my MA dissertation as I explored the way in which the Church of England is engaging with alt. worship.  At the time there was little in the way of sacrament within most Fresh Expressions of Church and the question of presidency is a sticking point for many in a variety of traditions.

Many denominations are involved in planting fresh expressions and not all of them require an ordained minister to preside, but many do.

Previously there has been no truly satisfactory solution postulated.  Bishop Graham suggests some ideas.

The leader or leaders of a fresh expression are not necessarily the ones who should preside. Leading the mission and the mission community are not the same thing as leading worship. An ordained minister can relate to a fresh expression, attend when they can without having to take responsibility and then act as a key link to the wider church when they preside. There needs to be a real connection between fresh expressions and the rest of the Church and this could strengthen it. When a fresh expression is linked in to a more traditional local church or group of churches it is possible to have a celebration of communion at one church, including, in its turn, the fresh expression and then each of the others has representatives who take the bread and wine to the other churches in the team. Churches in a more catholic tradition would be happy to use the reserved sacrament.

I suggest that we are at the beginning of the journey into fresh expressions.  This is a starting place will have to look at the theological implications of the movement as it develops.  We look towards christian unity and as we do this it is important that we foster links between the church historic and fresh expressions.  At the last supper Jesus instituted a meal that was a sign of the inclusive nature of God who invites humanity to eat with him.  It is a tragedy that many church structures turn this meal into a sign of division.  With that in mind it is good that the issue is being explored as we move forward as a mixed economy church.

Each fresh expression needs to find a way forward that is appropriate to its own cultural and denominational tradition and it is the responsibility of the leaders of each denomination to address real issues being raised by innovative mission. This is not a time for breaking the rules, but it time to ensure that new Christian communities can be fed by both Word and Sacrament!

9 Responses

  1. the Methodist movement did it pretty well for a while!

  2. well it was a tongue in cheek way of suggesting that we took services in a different direction. Most Methodist churches will have more ‘preaching’ services than services of sacrament. Of course the Methodist Church has it’s roots in being a fresh expression of the Anglican Church!

  3. But there is still a sacramental expression within Methodism. The faithful are baptised and bread and juice is shared 😉

    [I think you and I need a page dedicated to the fact that we went to college together and generally take the schmichael out of each other and the respective denominations at every given opportunity]

  4. Thanks for this, its interesting and needs to be wrestled with and talked about a whole lot more. I find the inherited church at the moment a little unwilling to ‘adopt’ or buddy a local fresh expression in this way – the subject seems to elicit much grumbling about finances and not playing on a level playing field. All of which is unhelpful – if understandable – when as the leader of a odd shaped thing you are trying to find any way in which it can connect to the local church landscape.

    We are about to start a once a month community eucharist in our building with a meal after, presided over by a local Anglican priest which is our attempt to resolve this. Hopefully it will work out but its hard to ‘parachute’ someone in who isn’t usually with us.

  5. Breaking bread and sharing food together is a way of bringing people together. Hopefully it won’t be “parachuting in” but “joining together”.

    I hope it all goes well.

  6. Thanks Robb, you are right and its ok to start something and see where the Spirit takes it. Eating always works for me! I am really excited about it.

  7. Just to let you know we had it yesterday and it was fab 🙂

  8. Brilliant news!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: